Latest By
Category:
Armor
Artificial
Intelligence
Biology
Clothing
Communication
Computers
Culture
Data Storage
Displays
Engineering
Entertainment
Food
Input Devices
Lifestyle
Living Space
Manufacturing
Material
Media
Medical
Miscellaneous
Robotics
Security
Space Tech
Spacecraft
Surveillance
Transportation
Travel
Vehicle
Virtual
Person
Warfare
Weapon
Work
 |
Comments on Plagiarism In Science Fiction
When is it plagiarism to borrow from another writer? An aspiring sf writer wants to know. (Read
the complete story)
| "To quote a Tom Lehrer song: "Plagiarise! Plagiarise! Plagiarise!! Only call it: Research."
I was thinking of another concept actually. Not something as old and as well used as the space suit or tractor beam but the Ansible. The Ansible was invented by Le-Guin. She came up with the concept, as far as I know, and gave it a specific name, which is used in the book.
What happened? She coined a phrase and Card, in writing Ender's Game, used the Ansible, The Ansible, as a piece of technology in his book.
Basically, I think that if you need a piece of technology in your story and you have a name for it that fits into that specific theme, use that name. The characters should use words from their own vocabulary, not yours. But if a concept is so well know such as hover technology, a space suit, or laser weapons, you don't need to call it "Fly-Chassis", "Vacuum Shell" or... "Needler".
(Heard Nightfall again recently, couldn't help but poke fun at it.)" (Sabre Runner 4/10/2008 12:57:10 PM) |
| "The Ansible is a good example; LeGuin coined the name, but she did not create the concept. To name one example, James Blish writes about the Dirac transmitter in his famous 1950's Cities in Flight series. The Dirac transmitter provided instantaneous communication across the galaxy (and on a party line, no less - anyone could listen). The device was named after the real-life Nobel Laureate physicist Paul Dirac." (Bill Christensen 4/10/2008 6:54:24 PM) |
| "Robert Heinlein (I believe) coined the term "Waldo" for remotely controlled manipulators and I have read numerous other books that also used this word for the same reason. I always took it as a tribute to a scifi master more than plagiarism." (Ken V 4/12/2008 7:28:21 AM) |
| "And don't forget all the words like Gymbal, which were invented by Lewis Carrol." (Ashley 4/13/2008 9:58:17 AM) |
| "Hi, I hope people are still likely to view this thread! I am very interested in this because I have written a novel which, byt its very nature, could be construed as plagiarism. Basically, it is a Star Trek parody - though I'd like to make it clear that I am Star Trek fan myself (the Kirk generation, that is) and the novel does celebrate the greatness of the series, as well and gently lampoon it. It features characters who are very similar to Kirk and crew, and this is a feature of the story. By that I mean it is not just a parody, but it is vital to the plot that the characters are so similar to the cast of Star Trek. There are also a couple of 20th Century characters who know all about - and are fans of - Star Trek, and are amazed to see these Kirk-like characters when they are accidentally zapped into the future. Anyway, I know how rubbish the idea sounds, but that's not the point! The point is, am I allowed to actually refer to the characters from the series? The characters in my novel do have different names (eg John T. Kork, Spoll, Sulin) and are definitely not the characters from Star Trek, but the similarity is obvious both to the audience and to the 20th century characters. In short, I have constantly refered to Star Trek, its characters and technologies, but the characters and technologies actually present in my story are different, so I haven't actually nicked anything from Star Trek, I've just refered to it. But I have refered to it by name. Is this plagiarism or breach of copyright? Any advice on this would be very welcome!" (Antony W 7/1/2009 12:45:31 AM) |
Get more information on Plagiarism In Science Fiction
Leave a comment:
Tediously, spammers have returned; if you have a comment, send it to bill at this site (include the story name) and I'll post it.
More Articles
Robotic Barber Programmed With a Number of Styles
'He found a barber shop which, he thought, would be good for an idle hour.'
Humanoid Boxing Robot KO's Opponent - It's A Knockout!
'Thirty rounds of fighting is tough work. Even for machines.'
Caterpillar Electric Mining Loader Not Yet Ready For Moon
'...the excavations were already in progress, for he saw gray slopes of rubble.'
Centipede Robots Down On The Farm
'...the walking mills of Puffy Products began to tread delicately on their centipede legs across the wheat fields of Kansas.'
Anthropic's Claude AI Creates Legal Citation From Whole Cloth
'Here is a Clerk that would work incessantly, and neither eat, sleep, want payment, or grumble.'
Students Vie For Lunar Regolith Mining Robot Prize
'About time you got here,' the astronaut said.
'They Erased My Memory' Says Ariana Grande
'...using a neutralizing electronic impulse.'
Solitary Black Hole Wanders In Space
'...the Hole is something like a vortex or a whirlpool?'
Spaceplane From Virgin Atlantic
'ZARNAK, YOU'RE TO COMMAND A SCOUTING EXPEDITION --- FIND OUT WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT!'
DARPA Wants 'Large Bio-Mechanical Space Structures'
'These are your rudimentary seed packages... Some will combine in place to form more complicated structures.'
Robot Hand Creeps Along, Separate From It's Owner
'The crawling... object was V-Stephen's surgeon-hand...'
Taikonauts Exercise In China's Tiangong Space Station
'Joe got out the gravity-simulator harnesses...'
Korean Exoskeleton Suit F1 Helps You Put It On
'Better late than never.'
Have AI Researchers Given Up On 'Bio-Babies'?
'You couldn't have the capstone without the pyramid to hold it up.'
Bunker Busters and Bore-Pellets
'The first revelation of the new Soviet bore-pellets.'
'Spikeless' Brand Swizzle Stick Detects Spiked Drinks
'the unobtrusive inspections with tiny remote-cast snoopers...'
Heart Patches Grown In The Lab Repair Hearts
I'm hoping that this procedure becomes a normal part of medical practice!
Humanoid Robots Spotted In Homes Performing Household Chores
'... nothing was perfected until M. Pantalon announced the completion of his automatic valet.'
Musk Proposes Sites For Martian Cities
'...its streets were of remarkable width, with few or no buildings so high as mosques, churches, State-offices, or palaces in Tellurian cities.'
Bambot Open Source Cheap Delivery Robot
'Not since the time he rewired the delivery robot...'
